Game recap

Buccaneers @ Bengals

2026 Wk 1 · CIN 33, TB 27

Cincinnati's offense produced only two touchdowns on its own drives, and both came right after a recovery: one started at the Tampa Bay 33, the other after the touchback. Take the fumbles away and the Bengals offense scored 9 points. Four lost fumbles is a 1-in-440 team-game event, and a team that does it almost never wins; Tampa Bay was still within 6 with 3:25 left, and never touched the ball again because Cincinnati converted three first downs and knelt.

FanIQ Research · September 14, 2026 · 6 facts, every one from the play-by-play

Three straight Tampa Bay possessions ended in lost fumbles. Cincinnati scored a touchdown off each one.

Rare

Tampa Bay's second, third, and fourth possessions all ended with a Cincinnati recovery, and the Bengals scored a touchdown after every one: Demetrius Knight Jr.'s 27-yard return on the first, a 7-play drive to Mike Gesicki after the second, and a 12-play, 80-yard drive to Chase Brown's 5-yard run after the third. A fourth lost fumble in the fourth quarter set up the 32-yard field goal. 24 of Cincinnati's 33 points came off fumbles. Losing four fumbles on scrimmage plays has happened 33 times in 14,580 team-games since 1999, and those teams went 5-28.

Tampa Bay's four lost fumbles and Cincinnati's next points

Qtr	Clock	Fumble	Recovered at	Cincinnati's next points	Score after
1	6:29	Mayfield sacked by Myles Murphy and Barrett Carter	TB 27	Knight Jr. 27-yard return TD, same play	CIN 7, TB 3
1	5:38	Bucky Irving after a 7-yard catch	TB 33	Burrow 2-yard TD pass to Gesicki, 7 plays	CIN 14, TB 3
2	12:15	Mayfield scramble at the CIN 4	End zone, touchback	Chase Brown 5-yard TD run, 12 plays, 80 yards	CIN 21, TB 3
4	10:41	Mayfield sacked by Boye Mafe	TB 44	McPherson 32-yard FG	CIN 33, TB 20

Team-games with 4+ lost fumbles on scrimmage plays, 2022 to 2026

Season	Week	Game	Team	Lost fumbles	Result
2026	1	TB @ CIN	TB	4	L 27-33
2025	17	DET @ MIN	DET	4	L 10-23
2025	3	PIT @ NE	NE	4	L 14-21
2024	10	PHI @ DAL	DAL	4	L 6-34
2022	4	JAX @ PHI	JAX	4	L 21-29

Since 1999: teams that lost 4+ fumbles on scrimmage plays in a game

Team-games	With 4+ lost fumbles	Won	Lost	Decided by 7 or fewer
14,580	33	5	28	13

Why it matters. Cincinnati's offense produced only two touchdowns on its own drives, and both came right after a recovery: one started at the Tampa Bay 33, the other after the touchback. Take the fumbles away and the Bengals offense scored 9 points. Four lost fumbles is a 1-in-440 team-game event, and a team that does it almost never wins; Tampa Bay was still within 6 with 3:25 left, and never touched the ball again because Cincinnati converted three first downs and knelt.

Ja'Marr Chase finished with 12 yards. The Bengals won anyway, and Mike Gesicki led them with 78.

Anomaly

Chase saw 4 targets and caught 2 for 12 yards. In 79 regular-season games he has been held to 12 or fewer yards three times, and Cincinnati is 2-1 in those games. Joe Burrow still threw for 254 yards on 25 of 35 by spreading the ball: nine Bengals caught a pass, and Gesicki (5 for 78 and the 2-yard touchdown) and Tee Higgins (3 for 59) carried the load.

Chase's lowest receiving-yard games, regular season (79 games)

Season	Week	Opponent	Targets	Catches	Yards	Result
2021	15	DEN	4	1	3	W 15-10
2023	11	BAL	7	2	12	L 20-34
2026	1	TB	4	2	12	W 33-27
2023	18	CLE	6	4	19	W 31-14
2025	4	DEN	8	5	23	L 3-28

Cincinnati receiving, this game

Player	Targets	Catches	Yards	TD
Mike Gesicki	7	5	78	1
Tee Higgins	6	3	59	0
Samaje Perine	3	3	30	0
Chase Brown	6	5	22	0
Drew Sample	3	3	19	0
Dohnte Meyers	1	1	18	0
Ja'Marr Chase	4	2	12	0
Andrei Iosivas	3	2	12	0
Tanner Hudson	1	1	4	0

Why it matters. Chase is the player every Cincinnati passing game plan runs through, so a 12-yard day usually means the whole offense stalled. This time the targets went to the tight ends and backs: Gesicki, Perine, Brown, Sample, and Hudson combined for 17 catches and 153 yards. The win came from field position and turnovers, not from Chase, which is why the Bengals scored 33 with their best receiver a footnote.

A defense that ranked 29th in 2025 held Tampa Bay to minus 0.185 EPA per play, its second-best game in 18

Comparison

Cincinnati allowed plus 0.130 EPA per play across the 2025 regular season, 29th of 32 teams. Against Tampa Bay the number was minus 0.185 on 51 pass and run plays, with 4 sacks and 4 fumble recoveries. Of the 18 games since the start of 2025, only the Week 13 win at Baltimore was better.

Offensive EPA per play allowed, 2025 regular season (lower is better)

Rank	Team	Plays	EPA/play allowed
1	HOU	982	-0.131
2	SEA	1061	-0.116
3	JAX	1030	-0.105
28	TEN	992	0.101
29	CIN	1035	0.130
30	WAS	1073	0.143
31	NYJ	1053	0.147
32	DAL	1027	0.167

Cincinnati's best defensive games by EPA per play allowed, 2025 regular season plus this game

Season	Week	Opponent	Plays	EPA/play allowed	Sacks
2025	13	BAL	56	-0.340	3
2026	1	TB	51	-0.185	4
2025	18	CLE	52	-0.125	6
2025	16	MIA	58	-0.057	0
2025	1	CLE	71	-0.051	2

Why it matters. Cincinnati's 2025 problem was a defense that turned average offenses into good ones, so the question for 2026 is whether the unit can win a game on its own. This one did: the Knight Jr. return touchdown alone was worth 7 points, and the offense scored 9 in the entire second half. One game against a Tampa Bay offense that ranked 20th last season is a small sample, and the fumbles inflate the EPA figure, but the 4 sacks involved five different rushers (Murphy, Carter, Jenkins, Allen, Mafe), which is harder to fake.

Cincinnati's offense: plus 0.274 EPA per play before halftime, minus 0.277 after, on exactly 31 plays each

Split

Cincinnati's first 31 pass and run plays produced 183 yards, a 51.6 percent success rate, and a 24-10 halftime lead. The next 31 produced 169 yards but minus 0.277 EPA per play; the interception Josiah Trotter returned 38 yards for a touchdown cost 7.5 expected points by itself. Every second-half Cincinnati point came from Evan McPherson's leg. Tampa Bay went the other way, from minus 0.307 to minus 0.025, and outscored the Bengals 17-9 after the break.

Offense by half (pass and run plays)

Team	Half	Plays	EPA/play	Yards	Success rate
CIN	1st	31	+0.274	183	51.6%
CIN	2nd	31	-0.277	169	41.9%
TB	1st	29	-0.307	168	44.8%
TB	2nd	22	-0.025	115	50.0%

Points by half

Team	1st half	2nd half	Final
CIN	24	9	33
TB	10	17	27

Why it matters. A 14-point halftime lead is where an offense usually shortens the game, and Cincinnati did shorten it, but without scoring a touchdown. Three second-half field goals answered every Tampa Bay score and kept the lead at 10 or more from 14:09 of the fourth quarter until Mayfield's touchdown at 3:25. The scoreboard says the plan worked; the per-play numbers say the second-half offense handed the game to the defense and the kicker.

McPherson from 55 and 58: a two-long-kick game has happened 21 times since 1999, 13 of them since 2023

Milestone

Evan McPherson went 4 for 4, and the 55-yarder in the third quarter and the 58-yarder in the fourth were the first time he made two kicks of 55 or more yards in one game. He is now 9 of 14 from that range in his career. The other kicker on the field, Chase McLaughlin, had a 65 and 58 game against Philadelphia in Week 4 of last season. What used to happen about once every few seasons happened 7 times in 2025 alone.

Kicker-games with two or more made field goals of 55+ yards, 2024 to 2026

Season	Week	Game	Kicker	Makes of 55+
2026	1	TB @ CIN	Evan McPherson	55, 58
2025	18	KC @ LV	Daniel Carlson	55, 60
2025	17	NO @ TEN	Charlie Smyth	56, 57
2025	14	DAL @ DET	Brandon Aubrey	57, 55, 63
2025	8	GB @ PIT	Chris Boswell	56, 56
2025	4	PHI @ TB	Chase McLaughlin	65, 58
2025	2	LA @ TEN	Joey Slye	55, 57
2025	1	PIT @ NYJ	Chris Boswell	56, 60
2024	18	SEA @ LA	Joshua Karty	58, 57
2024	16	TB @ DAL	Brandon Aubrey	58, 58
2024	2	CHI @ HOU	Ka'imi Fairbairn	56, 59
2024	1	PIT @ ATL	Chris Boswell	57, 56

Two-long-kick games by season, 1999 to 2026 (21 total)

Season	Games
2004	1
2012	1
2015	1
2017	2
2020	2
2022	1
2023	1
2024	4
2025	7
2026	1

Field goals of 55+ yards

Kicker or league	Attempts	Made	Rate
Evan McPherson, career	14	9	64.3%
League, 2025 regular season	114	73	64.0%

Why it matters. The 58-yarder came right after the interception return had cut the lead to 27-20 and pushed it back to two scores; the 55-yarder had stretched a 24-10 lead to 27-10. The league context matters as much as the kick: 13 of the 21 two-long-kick games in the whole database have come since 2023, so a 55-yard attempt is now a routine call rather than a desperation one. McPherson's 64 percent from that range matches the 2025 league rate almost exactly.

Tampa Bay put up 27 points at minus 0.185 EPA per play, a mix seen in under 1 percent of team-games since 1999

Anomaly

Baker Mayfield completed 23 of 28 for 216 yards with no touchdown pass, took 4 sacks, and the offense lost 4 fumbles; its 51 pass and run plays averaged minus 0.185 EPA. The 27 points came from a 38-yard interception return, two field goals, and two short touchdown runs, Bucky Irving from 10 yards and Mayfield from 9. Only 136 of 14,566 team-games since 1999 paired 27 or more points with an offense that inefficient. The Buccaneers were on the other side of one a year ago: the Jets did it against them in Week 3 of 2025 and lost 29-27.

Tampa Bay's 27 points, by source

Qtr	Clock	Play	Score after
1	9:12	Chase McLaughlin 34-yard FG	TB 3, CIN 0
2	1:54	Bucky Irving 10-yard TD run	CIN 21, TB 10
3	3:46	McLaughlin 51-yard FG	CIN 27, TB 13
3	2:24	Josiah Trotter 38-yard interception return TD	CIN 27, TB 20
4	3:25	Mayfield 9-yard TD run	CIN 33, TB 27

Teams with 27+ points and offensive EPA/play of -0.15 or worse, 2025 to 2026 (regular season and playoffs)

Season	Week	Game	Team	Plays	EPA/play	Pts	Opp pts
2026	1	TB @ CIN	TB	51	-0.185	27	33
2025	20	HOU @ NE	NE	62	-0.278	28	16
2025	12	JAX @ ARI	JAX	60	-0.188	27	24
2025	10	CLE @ NYJ	NYJ	45	-0.295	27	20
2025	10	JAX @ HOU	JAX	56	-0.236	29	36
2025	7	HOU @ SEA	SEA	65	-0.248	27	19
2025	3	NYJ @ TB	NYJ	61	-0.185	27	29
2025	1	MIN @ CHI	MIN	51	-0.177	27	24

Since 1999

Team-games with play data	27+ pts at -0.15 EPA/play or worse	Share
14,566	136	0.9%

Why it matters. Points and efficiency usually move together, so a gap this wide says the scoreboard was built by the defense and by field position rather than by the drives. Seven of the 27 came with the offense on the bench, and Mayfield's 82 percent completion rate hides that his completions averaged under 10 yards while four sacks and four lost fumbles erased whole possessions. For Tampa Bay the encouraging read is the second half, when the same offense ran at minus 0.025 per play and the Buccaneers outscored Cincinnati 17-9; the concern is that it all came against a defense that ranked 29th last season.

FanIQ answers any NFL stats question with receipts, on your phone.

Get FanIQ free Get it on Google Play